This project advanced the institutional history of the field of textbook research by taking the Georg Eckert Institute as an example and thus moving into the second stage of the working field for history. Moreover it links directly to two other projects. Firstly to the “History beyond Borders” project, which studies the history of textbook revision from a European perspective; an area in which the GEI has played a central role. Secondly to the biography of Georg Eckert, which is currently being written by the GEI-associated history educationalist, Heike Mätzing.
The exploration of the institute’s history is of dual significance. It is first and foremost a critical analysis, from an institutional and historical perspective, of the origins of institutional textbook research. This analysis is based on the presupposition that textbook revision and textbook research were originally analogous with one another and that textbook research as a field in its own right only evolved thematically and methodologically, separate from revision and practical work on textbooks, particularly in conflict societies, in the last third of the twentieth century. Secondly it is evident that the history of textbook research can not be written independently of the diverse activities in the field of textbook revision and consultation. It is precisely this analysis of practical work on textbooks which incorporates the examination of the networks, the major stakeholders, the respective political contexts, the conflicts of interest and the spatial relationships that are, equally, the constituents of textbook research
The Georg Eckert Institute is therefore an excellent case study to use for research into this process, as not only did the institute’s founder Georg Eckert managed to establish textbook research as a new field of academic research at the Braunschweig Teacher College in the first decades after the second world war, but he also managed to combine this with practical guidelines for textbook work, primarily with the political aim of reconciliation. The Georg Eckert Institute, which was founded in 1975, one year after the death of its “guiding spirit”, grew to be one of the world’s leading institutions in the field of gathering and researching teaching materials for geography and history as well as social studies. The GEI has always regarded itself as an academic institute that not only established the field of textbook research but also largely developed and shaped it. The GEI has also made an important, and internationally recognised, contribution to the sphere of textbook revision. Initially between Germany and her neighbours, and former enemies, and later in Europe and beyond, the GEI has played a significant role in the mediation of textbook conflicts and acted as advisor to international organisations such as UNESCO and the Council of Europe.
The GEI’s history therefore offers answers to the questions of under which societal conditions textbooks came to the attention of academic research, how a new academic field was structured and institutionalised and how that field adapted to social, educational and scientific policy fluctuations, and to what extent and in what way the academic and transfer-oriented activities overlap with regards the stakeholders, institutions, aims and interests. Against this background the project also examined how changes in academic perspectives or political and financial steering instruments have altered textbook research in view of the shift from bilateral cooperation to global interconnectedness. At the same time the project focused on a comparative analysis of institutes undertaking textbook research and work on textbooks and the associated competition and cooperation at organisational level and the financing within the framework of regional, national or international institutions.
-
Results
Publications
- Bode, M., Defrance, C., Fuchs, E., Pfeil, U., Sammler, S., Strobel, T. (2021): Georg Eckert: A Driving Force in International Textbook Revision and Cultural Policy. Eckert. Dossiers 2. urn:nbn:de:0220-2021-0064.
- Fuchs, E., Henne, K., Sammler, S. (2018): Schulbuch als Mission: Die Geschichte des Georg-Eckert-Institutes. Cologne: Böhlau.
- Sammler, S. (2018): Wie folgenreich können bilaterale Schulbuchgespräche sein? Überlegungen am Beispiel der zweiten Generation der deutsch-französischen Schulbuchgespräche (1951–1967). In: Rainer Bendick, Ulrich Bongertmann, Marc Charbonnier, Franck Collard, Martin Stupperich, Hubert Tison (eds): Deutschland und Frankreich – Geschichtsunterricht für Europa. Die deutsch-französischen Schulbuchgespräche im europäischen Kontext [France – Allemagne. L’enseignement de l’histoire pour l’Europe. Les rencontres franco-allemandes sur les manuels scolaires dans le contexte européen]. Frankfurt a. M., p. 85–96.
- Sammler, S. (2017): Georg Eckert und die internationale Schulbucharbeit in Braunschweig (1946 bis 1974) In: Dieter Dowe, Eckhardt Fuchs, Heike Christina Mätzing, Steffen Sammler (eds): Georg Eckert. Grenzgänger zwischen Wissenschaft und Politik. Eckert. Die Schriftenreihe, 146. Göttingen: V&R unipress, p. 223–236.
- Fuchs, E., Sammler, S., Henne, K. (2016): الكتب الدراسية بين التقاليد والتجديد . رحلة في تاريخ معهد جيورج إكارت [Al-kuttub al-dirasiyya baina al-taqalid wa al-tagdid. Rihla fi tarih ma’had Gijurg-Ickart]. Braunschweig: Georg-Eckert-Institut.
- Sammler, S. (2016): Die Institutionalisierung der internationalen Schulbucharbeit auf dem Gebiet der Geschichte. Das internationale Schulbuchinstitut in Braunschweig (1951-1965). In: Jürgen Elwert (ed.): Geschichte jenseits der Universität. Netzwerke und Organisationen in der frühen Bundesrepublik. Historische Mitteilungen – Beiheft 94. Stuttgart, p. 169–185.
- Sammler, S. (2016): Schulbuchgespräche in friedenspädagogischer Absicht. Die Revision der Geschichtsbücher im Versöhnungsprozess nach 1945. In: Corine Defrance, Ulrich Pfeil (eds): Verständigung und Versöhnung nach dem „Zivilisationsbruch“? Deutschland in Europa nach 1945. Schriftenreihe der Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung, 1731. Bonn: bpb, p. 605–623.
- Fuchs, E., Sammler, S. (2015): The Establishment of the Georg Eckert Institute in the Summer of 1975. How Textbook Research Was Given a New Future in Braunschweig Following the Death of Georg Eckert. Eckert. Bulletin 15, p. 32–35.
- Fuchs, E., Sammler, S., Henne, K. (2015): Schulbücher zwischen Tradition und Innovation. Ein Streifzug durch die Geschichte des Georg-Eckert-Instituts. Braunschweig: Georg Eckert Institute.
- Nouvel-Kirschleger, M., Sammler, S. (2015): Between National Tradition and Bilateral Dialogue: Teaching the First World War in France and Germany to Build Lasting Peace. Studi sulla Formazione 18 (2), p. 33–45.
- Sammler, S. (2015): De la révision des récits de guerre à l’enseignement de la paix dans les manuels scolaires : l’exemple franco-allemand au sortir de la Seconde Guerre mondiale. In: Antoine Coppolani, Charles-Philippe David, Jean-François Thomas (eds): La Fabrique de la Paix Acteurs, processus, mémoires. Quebec, p. 213–223.
- Nouvel-Kirschleger, M., Sammler, S. (2014): Construire une paix durable après 1945: L’enseignement des origines de la Première Guerre Mondiale en France et en Allemagne. Didactica Historica. Revue Suisse pour l’Enseignement de l’Histoire 1 (1), p. 71–76.
- Nouvel-Kirschleger, M., Sammler, S. (2014): Les manuels scolaires, outils pour la construction d'une paix durable au sortir de la Grande Guerre ? La Grande Guerre des manuels scolaires. Montpellier, France.